Freezing Eggs Raises Ethical Questions

Freezing a woman’s eggs and implanting them at a later time became the subject of medicine and scientific inquiry beginning in the 1800s.

The subject raised legal, religious, and moral questions affecting the status of the women impregnated and their children. The issue is a quandary in the twenty-first century, as scientific advancements race toward the ability to produce babies-to-order.

Freezing Eggs Raises Ethical Questions

There are Various Reasons for Freezing a Woman’s Eggs

Laboratory experiments at freezing mammal eggs began in earnest in the 1960s. Twenty years later, scientists were freezing eggs (oocyte cryopreservation) of humans. Two decades later, a human baby was born from a frozen egg. In 2012, the success rate reached so high the procedure was no longer experimental. A start-up company, EggBanxx: Smart Women Freeze, was founded to explain, advocate, and finance access to the best care and support for women struggling to conceive when they are ready.

Vitrification, according to Dr. Beth Plants at the Fertility Centers of New England, is the ultra-rapid cooling of eggs, protecting them from fracturing when thawed. Modern science allows eggs to be extracted, frozen, stored, thawed, fertilized, and transferred to the uterus as embryos whenever the woman decides it’s her time to become pregnant. The women fall into three groups:

* Women with early stage cancers

* Women receiving assisted reproductive technologies but unwilling to freeze an embryo, and

* Women wanting to have children in the future, but social, sexual identity conflicts, economic, medical, financial, and religious considerations forefend their decision for “natural” birth, and they opt to freeze their eggs.

Reasons for Freezing Eggs

Suffice to say, 80 percent who opt to freeze their eggs make a lifestyle choice. They delay childbearing for career pursuits and finding the right partner. Cancer patients and others freezing their eggs for medical reasons are small in number. An article by Natalie Joos, Harper’s Bazaar online (May 12, 2015), lays out the issues, so even a man can understand a woman’s point of view.

Science has advanced further, and eggs can now be genetically modified. Scientists are working on modifying DNA of human egg cells through gene-editing. They are working to eliminate inherited familial diseases. Harvard Medical School is attempting to eliminate genes causing breast and ovarian cancers from being inherited.

Ethics of Egg Freezing

There are ethical questions about these procedures. Some scientists and doctors are fielding questions about making designer babies from cutting-edge genetic screening and modification of preimplantation of embryos; eggs can be frozen until the scientific technology improves to produce perfect children with traits mothers want in their offspring: sex, hair and eye color, athletic ability, and intelligence are just a few.

Scientific American in 2016 declares, “More oversight is needed to prevent misuse of new reproductive technologies.” Private sector companies and university scientists are working industriously in the field, but it is imperative there be outsourcers who can raise the ethical and moral questions, assess the work, and represent society’s interests. Perhaps, they may even need to prepare society for designer babies of unnatural selection.

Dr. Goldmeier was a Research and Teaching Fellow at Harvard University, where he received his Doctorate in Education. He is a former consultant to the US Surgeon General on federally funded Maternal and Child Health programs. Currently, he teaches international university students and serves as a business analyst and development consultant for companies and nonprofit organizations. His new ebook on Amazon is Healthcare Insights: Better Care Better Business.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>